"Casper is excited because this is his very first Valentine's Day and he has two valentines. One is his lifelong friend. The other is a new girl who just moved in next door." Casper's First Valentine's Day explores the real value of friendship with Casper at the wheel. As soon as Lucy and his new friend Tara visit, he realizes that he must make a choice. However, when Tara pushes him to decide between the two of them, he has to stop and think about what is right. In the end, does he have two valentines? Or none?