Caitlyn McCarty plans to marry her high school sweetheart, Bryan Johnson, and teach elementary school after graduating from Arbor University. But after Bryan's life turns upside down with an unexpected turn of events, Caty begins to question her goals and every decision she's ever made. Peter Criswell fell for green-eyed, opinionated Caitlyn when he first met her. However, her determination to hold onto a dream frustrates him. Sometimes you meet the right person at the wrong time, and falling for a woman who's caught between her parents' wants versus her own desires isn't always easy. When the foundation of Bryan Johnson's relationship with Caitlyn is tested not once, but twice, he faces the possibility of losing the only girl he's loved since high school. When Caty does make up her mind, will she stand by her man or run into the arms of another?